top of page

Passwords vs. Passkeys: What's the Difference and Which is More Secure?

Writer: Shawn Donaldson
Shawn Donaldson
4 days ago
6 min read

A passkey sits on top of a laptop keyboard.

Passwords have been the standard method of protecting online accounts for decades. From email and banking to business applications and company networks, nearly every digital service requires some form of authentication. However, as cyberattacks become more sophisticated, traditional passwords are increasingly becoming a security weakness.


Today, passkeys are emerging as a more secure and convenient alternative. Major technology companies and software providers are adopting passkey technology to help protect user accounts from phishing, stolen credentials, and unauthorized access.


But what exactly are passkeys, how do they compare to traditional passwords, and should businesses consider making the switch?


Understanding the differences between passwords and passkeys is an important step toward improving your organization's cybersecurity.


What is a Traditional Password?


A password is a secret combinator of characters used to verify someone's identity before granting access to an account or system. Passwords typically consist of letters, numbers, and special characters.


Although passwords are familiar and relatively easy to implement, they come with several security challenges.


One of the biggest problems is that passwords rely heavily on user behavior. Employees must create strong, unique passwords for every account, remember them, and update them when necessary. Unfortunately, many people reuse passwords across multiple platforms or choose combinations that are easy to remember but also easy for attackers to guess.


Cybercriminals take advantage of these habits through several common attack methods.


  • Phishing: Attackers send fraudulent emails or messages designed to trick employees into entering their login credentials on fake websites.

  • Brute-force attacks: Automated tools repeatedly attempt different password combinations until they find the correct one.

  • Credential stuffing: Stolen usernames and passwords from one data breach are tested against other websites and business applications.

  • Password spraying: Attackers attempt commonly used passwords across multiple accounts to avoid triggering account lockouts.


Even a relatively strong password can become a security risk if it is stolen, reused, or entered into a fraudulent login page.


What is a Passkey?


A passkey is a passwordless authentication method that allows users to sign in using a device-based credential instead of typing in a traditional password.


Passkeys use public-key cryptography, which means two mathematically related keys are created:


  • Public key: Stored with the website or service you're accessing.

  • Private key: Stored securely on your device and never shared with the website.


When you attempt to sign in, the website sends a challenge that your device must verify using the private key. You then authenticate using a familiar method, such as facial recognition, a fingerprint, or your device's PIN.


For example, instead of entering a password to access your work account, you might simply select the passkey login option and verify your identity using Windows Hello or your phone's fingerprint reader.


The website verifies the cryptographic response without ever receiving your private key.


This makes passkeys significantly more resistant to any of the attacks that target traditional passwords.


Passwords vs. Passkeys: The Key Differences


With both methods are designed to protect accounts, they approach authentication very differently.


  1. Security Against Phishing


Traditional passwords can be stolen through phishing attacks. If an employee enters their credentials into a convincing fake login page, an attacker may be able to use those credentials to access the legitimate account.


Passkeys are designed to prevent this type of attack. They are tied to the legitimate website or application's domain, meaning they will not authenticate on a fraudulent website pretending to be the real one.


  1. Password Reuse


Password reuse is a major security concern for businesses. If an employee uses the same password for multiple accounts, a breach involving one service could put several other accounts at risk.


Passkeys use unique cryptographic credentials for each service, eliminating the need to remember and reuse passwords.


  1. Convenience and User Experience


Traditional passwords require users to remember and manually enter credentials. This can become frustrating when employees manage dozens of business applications.


Passkeys simplify the process. Users can authenticate with a fingerprint, facial recognition, or device PIN, making sign-ins faster and reducing the burden of password management.


  1. Risk of Credential Theft


Passwords can be captured through phishing, keylogging malware, data breaches, or insecure storage practices.


Passkeys are more resistant to credential theft because the private key stays on the user's device and is not transmitted to the website during authentication.


  1. Account Recovery


Passwords can typically be reset through email links, security questions, or administrator assistance.


Passkeys introduce different recovery considerations. If an employee loses their device, they may need to use a synchronized passkey on another device, a backup authentication method, or an organization's account recovery process.


Businesses need to establish clear procedures for managing lost devices and restoring account access.


Why Are Passkeys More Secure?


The biggest advantage of passkeys is that they eliminate many of the vulnerabilities associated with traditional passwords.


With passwords, authentication depends on keeping a secret combination of characters protected. Once that secret is exposed, attackers may be able to use it to impersonate the legitimate user.


Passkeys work differently. The private key never leaves the user's device during authentication, and the login process relies on cryptographic verification rather than sharing a reusable secret.


This provides several important security benefits.


  • Phishing resistance: Passkeys are tied to the legitimate website's domain, making them much harder to steal through fake login pages.

  • No reusable passwords: There is no traditional password for attackers to guess, reuse, or obtain from a password database.

  • Stronger authentication: Public-key cryptography provides a more secure foundation for verifying user identities.

  • Reduced employee mistakes: Employees no longer need to create, remember, or reuse complicated passwords.


It's important to remember that passkeys are not a complete replacement for cybersecurity. Compromised devices, malicious software, weak account recovery procedures, and poorly configured systems can still create security risks.


Passkeys are one important layer of a broader cybersecurity strategy.


Should Businesses Switch to Passkeys?


For businesses, adopting passkeys can be an effective way to strengthen account security while simplifying the employee login experience.


Employees regularly access sensitive information through email platforms, cloud applications, financial systems, and internal business software/ Every login represents a potential entry point for cybercriminals.


Reducing reliance on traditional passwords can help limit the opportunities attackers have to gain unauthorized access.


However, businesses should approach passkey adoption strategically.


Before making the transition, consider the following:


  1. Reviewing Software Compatibility


Not every business application supports passkeys. Review the applications your employees use regularly and determine which ones offer passkey authentication.


  1. Establish Device Security Policies


Passkeys are tied to devices, so protecting those devices is essential. Make sure company computers and mobile devices have appropriate security controls, including encryption, endpoint protection, and access restrictions.


  1. Create Account Recovery Procedures


Employees need a reliable way to regain access if a device is lost, damaged, or replaced. Establish recovery procedure that verify employee identities before restoring access.


  1. Educate Employees


Although passkeys simplify authentication, employees should understand how they work and why they are being introduced. Training can help prevent confusion and reinforce other important security practices.


  1. Maintain Additional Security Layers


Passkeys should be part of a larger security strategy that includes multi-factor authentication where appropriate, endpoint protection, employee awareness training, and ongoing monitoring.


Are Passwords Going Away?


Not quite. Although passkeys are gaining adoption, traditional passwords will remain part of the authentication landscape for the foreseeable future.


Many business applications still rely on passwords, and some organizations have legacy systems that cannot easily support newer authentication methods.


Additionally, passkey adoption requires compatible software, devices, and account management procedures.


For most businesses, the transition will happen gradually. Organizations can begin by enabling passkeys for supported applications while maintaining strong password policies for systems that still require them.


The important thing is to recognize that traditional password security is no longer enough on its own.


Strengthen Your Business's Cybersecurity with Encompass IT


Cybersecurity threats continue to evolve, and the methods businesses use to protect their information need to evolve with them.


Whether it's implementing passkeys, strengthening multi-factor authentications, securing Microsoft 365 accounts, or improving employee security awareness, having the right IT strategy can make a significant difference in protecting your organization.


At Encompass IT, we help businesses identify security weaknesses, implement modern technology solutions, and build stronger cybersecurity strategies.


Our team works directly with businesses to ensure their technology us secure, reliable, and prepared for the challenges ahead.


Want to know if your business is using the right authentication and security practices? Contact Encompass IT to learn how we can help strengthen your cybersecurity.



 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page